Skip to content
Serenity Plumbing CoRaleigh, NC plumbersAnswered 24/7(919) 557-9058

Water heater size calculator

Pick how many people live in the home, how many showers run at once and the fuel. The calculator suggests a tank size and a tankless flow rate.

Two water heaters side by side in a garage, a tank unit and a wall-hung tankless unit

Winter water entering Raleigh homes runs cold enough that a tankless unit has to lift it roughly 70 degrees to reach 120.

Tank water heater

...

Tankless water heater

...

Want it checked against your house? Call (919) 557-9058 or see water heater replacement.

Tank size is about the busiest hour

A tank water heater is sized by its first-hour rating: how many gallons of hot water it can deliver in the busiest hour of the day, starting full. That number is printed on the yellow EnergyGuide label and in the spec sheet. A gas tank recovers faster than an electric tank of the same size, which is why a 40 gallon gas unit can keep up with a household that would need a 50 or 65 gallon electric unit.

For most homes the busiest hour is the morning, when showers stack up back to back. The calculator counts roughly 20 gallons of hot water per shower in that hour plus a little for sinks and a dishwasher, then matches the total to common tank sizes.

Tankless size is about flow at once

A tankless heater never runs out, but it can only heat so many gallons per minute at a time. The question is how many fixtures run together, not how many people live in the home. Two showers at about 2 gallons per minute each plus a kitchen faucet is a common peak.

Winter matters here. Water entering Triangle homes in January is far colder than in August, so the heater has to raise it about 70 degrees to reach 120. Manufacturers list flow at different temperature rises; read the number for a rise of around 70 degrees, not the bigger summer number.

Before you buy

Gas tankless units often need a larger gas line and new venting, and whole-home electric tankless units can need more electrical service than many houses have. Replacing a water heater in Raleigh generally needs a permit, which we handle. If you are unsure, call and a plumber will size it against your actual gas line, panel and fixtures.

Related: water heater replacement, tankless water heater installation, hot water recirculation pump, tank or tankless for a Raleigh home.

Water heater sizing questions

Is a bigger tank always better?

No. An oversized tank keeps more water hot around the clock, which costs money in standby loss, and it takes up more room. Sizing to the busiest hour, with a little margin, is the better target. If you regularly run out, the first-hour rating matters more than the gallon number.

Why does a tankless heater give lukewarm water in winter?

It is usually undersized for winter. A unit that delivers plenty of flow in summer may only manage about two thirds of that in January, when incoming water is coldest. Sizing to a rise of about 70 degrees avoids the problem.

Can I keep my tank size when I switch from electric to gas?

Often you can go down a size. Gas tanks recover faster, so a 40 gallon gas heater can cover what took 50 gallons in electric. The new gas line and venting are part of that job, and we check both before quoting.

Plumbing problem right now?

Call and a person answers, day or night. A plumber from our downtown Raleigh office comes to you.

Call (919) 557-9058
Call (919) 557-9058 · 24/7